Image of Atom

Tylenol vs Generic Brand Science Fair Projects

Take on Tylenol vs generic brand science fair projects for students.
menu

Advanced

Pain reliever science fair projects test brand specificity...

image of detective

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Over the Counter Medications

Over the counter medications include things like cold medicine and pain relievers. Brand name OTC medications are usually more expensive that generic brands, but are they any better?

EDU-36820 C2D Discovery Planet Digital Microscope Young Scientists Club Set 2 Discovery Planet EDU-41021 Maxscope Videoscope Student, HomeSchool & Adult Microscopes
Image of EDU-36820 C2D Discovery Planet Digital Microscope image of Young Scientist Club Set 2, weather, solids, liquids, gases, volcanoes image of Discovery Planet EDU-41021 Maxscope Videoscope Kit Image of Student Microscopes for School, Homeschooling, and Adults also  
Ages 8 and up   Ages 5 - 8 Ages 10 and up   Age 10 thru College  

 



Objectives/Goals

To determine if there is a significant difference in how long different dose forms of Tylenol and generic acetaminophen take to dissolve in the gastro-intestinal tract compared with Tylenol rapid release gels.

Methods/Materials

0.01M hydrochloric acid (at approximately 37.2C) was used as a model for gastro-intestinal conditions. This was stirred via a magnetic stirrer at a fixed speed and a 500 mg dose form of Tylenol or a generic acetaminophen was added. The time to obtain dissolution or uniform dispersal of the material was measured and the temperature recorded to ensure consistency. This was repeated in triplicate for each of 4 dose forms (3 Tylenol + 1 generic).

Results

The following Mean (+/- SD) results were obtained: Tylenol Rapid Release Gels - 103s (+/- 0), Tylenol EZ Tabs - 108s (+/- 1), Tylenol Caplets - 82s (+/- 15), Generic Acetaminophen Caplets - 440s (+/- 27). None of the dose forms fully dissolved under the experimental conditions due to the insoluble excipients added during the manufacture of the dose forms.

Conclusions/Discussion

The results demonstrated that the time required to disperse the various formulations of Tylenol did not vary significantly and therefore time to dispersion may not be an accurate model for actual dissolution. The only observation was that the generic acetaminophen took a significantly longer time (~ 4 times longer) to disperse than the Tylenol.
This experiment demonstrated that visual inspection is inadequate to determine Tylenol dissolution and a more specific analytical technique such as hplc is required to accurately measure the dissolution of the active ingredient (acetaminophen). As a result no conclusions could be made regarding the original objective. 3rd party contributor